The biblical story of Hagar and Ishmael gave artists an unusually powerful sequence of subjects: a dismissal at the threshold of a home, a mother and son wandering beneath an open sky, a vessel emptied of water, and an angel revealing the means of survival. Although the narrative belongs to the history of Abraham’s family, its emotional force lies with those sent away. Hagar’s sorrow, Ishmael’s vulnerability and the sudden appearance of divine help turn a story of inheritance and rivalry into a profound image of exile, endurance and providence.

Paintings of Hagar and Ishmael often concentrate on one of two moments from Genesis 21. The first is Abraham’s dismissal of Hagar and her son. The second is their rescue in the wilderness, when an angel directs Hagar towards water. These episodes are closely connected, yet they generate very different compositions. One is rooted in domestic architecture and painful human separation; the other unfolds in a landscape transformed by revelation.

Understanding the distinction between these scenes, and between Genesis 21 and Hagar’s earlier flight in Genesis 16, makes it easier to identify the subject in sacred art. It also reveals why artists could treat Hagar as a figure of grief, courage, displacement and divine recognition.

Who were Hagar and Ishmael?

Hagar appears in Genesis as an Egyptian servant in the household of Abraham and Sarah. Because Sarah had not borne a child, Hagar became the mother of Abraham’s first son, Ishmael. The resulting tensions between the two women form the background to two wilderness episodes that artists and viewers sometimes confuse.

In Genesis 16, Hagar is pregnant when she flees after conflict with Sarah. An angel finds her near a spring and tells her to return, promising that her descendants will be greatly multiplied. This encounter occurs before Ishmael’s birth.

Genesis 21 takes place years later, after Sarah has given birth to Isaac. Hagar does not flee voluntarily: Abraham sends her and Ishmael away. He gives her bread and a skin of water, and she enters the wilderness of Beersheba. When the water is exhausted, the crisis reaches its most painful point. Hagar places Ishmael apart from herself and withdraws because she cannot bear to witness his death.

God hears the boy, and an angel calls to Hagar. Her eyes are opened to a well, from which she fills the water skin and gives Ishmael a drink. The narrative concludes not with abandonment but with survival and promise: God remains with Ishmael as he grows.

Two episodes that shape the artistic tradition

Abraham dismissing Hagar and Ishmael

In dismissal scenes, the action frequently takes place beside a doorway, courtyard or substantial house. Abraham remains connected to the settled world of the household, while Hagar and Ishmael face the uncertain landscape beyond it. Architecture therefore does more than establish a setting. The threshold becomes the boundary between belonging and exclusion.

Artists could interpret Abraham’s gesture in several ways. An extended hand might suggest command, farewell, explanation or reluctant reassurance. Hagar may look back towards him, lower her eyes or turn towards the road. Ishmael can appear confused, sorrowful or closely attached to his mother. Bread, a bundle or a water vessel may signal the journey that is about to begin.

This moment is emotionally complex because Abraham is not normally shown as a triumphant patriarch. The biblical command has placed him in a painful position, and artists often present the departure as a fractured family scene. The drama emerges through gestures, gazes and physical distance rather than through violent action.

Hagar and the angel in the wilderness

The rescue scene exchanges the household threshold for wilderness. Hagar and Ishmael have reached the limits of their own resources, and the emptied water vessel becomes a sign of mortal danger. An angel enters the scene as messenger and guide, directing Hagar’s attention towards a well, spring or stream.

The water is the essential identifying motif. It is not merely a landscape detail but the visible means by which despair is reversed. Hagar may turn sharply towards the angel, raise her hands in surprise or follow the messenger’s pointing gesture. Ishmael commonly rests nearby, weakened by thirst, although his precise age and posture vary considerably among works.

The narrative’s movement is from inability to perception. The well is revealed when Hagar’s eyes are opened. For artists, this makes the story especially suited to gestures of looking and pointing: the angel indicates, Hagar sees, and water restores life.

How to recognise Hagar and Ishmael in art

The setting is often the quickest guide. A woman and boy leaving an older man at the entrance to a house probably represent the dismissal from Genesis 21. A distressed woman, an exhausted child and an angel near water are more likely to represent the wilderness rescue. A solitary pregnant woman meeting an angel beside a spring may instead belong to the earlier episode in Genesis 16.

A water skin, flask or small vessel can connect the two phases of the later story. At the dismissal it represents Abraham’s limited provision for the journey. In the wilderness it may lie empty before being filled again. Bread, travelling bundles and sparse vegetation further establish the conditions of exile.

Ishmael should not automatically be expected to look like an infant. The chronology in Genesis places his birth years before Isaac’s, and some artists accordingly portray him as a walking boy. Nicolaes Maes, for example, shows Ishmael old enough to stand beside Hagar at the moment of departure. Other artists adopted a younger child type to heighten vulnerability or to fit familiar compositions of a mother with a child. The age shown must therefore be judged from the individual work rather than assumed for the entire tradition.

Hagar is usually distinguished by her relationship to Ishmael rather than by a fixed personal attribute. Unlike many saints, she has no standard halo, emblem or form of dress. Her identity emerges from the narrative combination of mother, child, journey, water and angelic intervention.

Nicolaes Maes and the sorrow of dismissal

Nicolaes Maes’s Abraham Dismissing Hagar and Ishmael, signed and dated 1653, is among the most affecting treatments of the departure. Painted in oil on canvas, it is also the earliest known dated painting by Maes. He was about nineteen and emerging from his training under Rembrandt, whose artistic circle showed a sustained interest in biblical narratives expressed through intimate human emotion.

Rembrandt had treated the same subject in a 1637 etching, helping to establish a model in which the drama gathers around the entrance to Abraham’s home. Maes adapted this tradition while concentrating attention on the relationships among the three principal figures. The result is biblical history made immediate through the language of family separation.

Abraham appears to address or reassure Hagar rather than simply driving her away. Hagar and Ishmael are bound together by their downcast expressions and shared direction. Their sorrow is quiet, but the composition makes the consequences of the command unmistakable. The scene does not require a crowd or a distant panorama: the departure is conveyed through the closeness of bodies at the point where their paths divide.

Colour intensifies the encounter. Abraham wears a vivid red velvet robe, while Hagar’s red hat creates a visual echo across the group. Her white blouse and blue skirt contrast with Ishmael’s striped clothing and the red cloth at his waist. Behind them, a grey-blue sky is warmed by orange-yellow morning light. Sunrise is appropriate to a departure, yet its beauty does not soften the precariousness of what lies ahead.

The doorway is crucial. Abraham remains framed by the architecture of the household; Hagar and Ishmael stand at its edge, already oriented towards the exterior world. The threshold gives visible form to a change in status. They are close enough to touch Abraham, but they no longer belong within his home.

Francesco Maffei and divine help in the wilderness

Francesco Maffei’s Hagar and the Angel, painted around 1657, turns to the story’s second great moment. Maffei worked in Vicenza and Padua and was strongly shaped by Venetian painting. His elongated figures and loose brushwork lend the encounter a fluid, visionary character well suited to the appearance of a heavenly messenger.

Where Maes builds tension through the solidity of architecture and the restraint of a farewell, Maffei presents intervention. The wilderness is no longer simply the place into which Hagar has been expelled. It becomes the setting in which divine attention is made visible.

The angel’s role is practical as well as consoling. The messenger does not merely offer sympathy but directs Hagar towards the water that will preserve life. This emphasis distinguishes the scene from a general image of an angel comforting a grieving woman. The relationship among the angel’s gesture, Hagar’s response and the presence of water establishes the biblical subject.

Seen together, the Maes and Maffei paintings form a compelling narrative sequence, although they were not created as pendants. Maes shows human rejection at the household boundary; Maffei shows divine aid in the wilderness. One image closes a door, while the other opens Hagar’s eyes to a well.

The angel, the well and the meaning of providence

The angel in Hagar’s story embodies the conviction that exile does not place the vulnerable beyond divine notice. In Genesis 21, God hears Ishmael, and the angel addresses Hagar in her distress. The rescue therefore depends upon both hearing and seeing: the child’s voice is heard, and the mother is enabled to see the water before her.

Artists translated this structure into physical relationships. An angel may touch Hagar’s shoulder, descend into the landscape or point decisively towards a stream. Hagar’s body may pivot from Ishmael towards the messenger, turning the composition itself from grief to hope.

Jan Muller’s engraving Hagar in the Desert Consoled by an Angel, made around 1591, demonstrates that this iconography was established in Northern European art before the later seventeenth-century paintings. The angel touches Hagar and points towards a visible stream, while Ishmael lies beneath trees in a state of extreme weakness. The pointing hand joins revelation to the material fact of water.

Such images do not erase the severity of Hagar’s expulsion. Their power depends upon scarcity, fatigue and maternal fear. Yet the wilderness is not represented as spiritually empty. It is precisely there, beyond the security of Abraham’s household, that Hagar receives renewed assurance of Ishmael’s future.

Hagar as mother, exile and witness

Hagar occupies a distinctive place in sacred art because her story is experienced from the margins of a patriarchal household. She is a servant, a foreigner, a mother protecting her son and a woman twice encountered by an angel in the wilderness. Artists could therefore approach her narrative through domestic drama, landscape, maternal lament or supernatural revelation.

Her emotional range is equally important. In dismissal scenes she may embody shock, resignation or wounded dignity. In the wilderness she can appear overwhelmed by grief, attentive to the angel or newly animated by hope. Ishmael’s presence prevents the image from becoming an abstract allegory of exile. Her fear has a specific object: the life of her child.

The subject also complicates simple contrasts between household and wilderness. Abraham’s home offers material security but becomes the site of exclusion. The desert threatens death but also becomes the place of divine speech and life-giving water. Sacred art makes this reversal visible by moving the narrative from an enclosed doorway towards an expansive landscape.

Why the story remained compelling for artists

Hagar and Ishmael offered painters and printmakers a biblical story in which monumental themes could be expressed through recognisable human experience. Farewell, family conflict, migration, thirst and maternal grief require no elaborate theological apparatus to be understood. At the same time, the angel and the revealed well place these experiences within a sacred history of promise and providence.

The narrative also allowed artists to explore contrasts of exceptional visual clarity: architecture and wilderness, red robes and pale skies, stillness and sudden gesture, an empty vessel and abundant water. Whether treated with the psychological restraint of Maes or the visionary movement of Maffei, the story proceeds from separation towards survival.

At its heart, Hagar and Ishmael in art is a subject of being seen after being cast out. The doorway marks the pain of exclusion, but it is not the final image. Beyond it lie the angel, the well and the assurance that the wilderness will not have the last word.

Explore related art from Holy Masterpieces

Discover museum-inspired fine-art prints connected with this subject.

Abraham Dismissing Hagar and Ishmael — Nicolaes Maes

Hagar and the Angel — Francesco Maffei

Abraham rejects Hagar and Ismael — Josef Danhauser

Leave a comment

Please note: comments must be approved before they are published.